Friday, April 30, 2004

THE DIVISION BELL

Me: “ So what is happening with the next Project? …”
Boss: “ We are hoping that you will take a significant responsibility… Blah!! Blah!! Blah!! ”
Me: “ What’s in for me?”
Boss: “ I met with the management few days ago and we are working on a transition plan for you to move to the next level.”
Me: " To the next level?"
Boss: " Yes, next level."
Me: “ But, unfortunately... ”
Boss: “ But?”
Me: “ I am quitting.”
Boss: “ Quitting?”
Me: “ I am here for the next 1 month. June 4th will be my last day. I am headed to Business School. “
Boss: “ Business School?”
Me: “ Michigan Business School. “
Boss: (with a big smile) “ Good. Congratulations!! Great School.”
Me: “ Thank You. “
Me: “ I thought that it is my responsibility to tell you guys a month ahead so that we can work on a smooth transition for the team. “
Boss: “ I am very happy for you. We will miss you. “

Yes! I dropped the bomb today. Only a month left before I head to mid west to spend the few days before school with Ria. My living room is empty – one of the couches already sold. A bookshelf has been replaced with a bunch of books stashed in the corner. The study table is gone replaced with a side table – the printer carelessly lingering on the floor. (I never realized that the living room was so spacious.) The “Things to Do” List is glaring at me from the bare wall above my laptop. I can hear the medieval fan buzzing from the ceiling and this strange feeling of agoraphobia as the clock ticks away to midnight.

And then this sudden flashback in my mind of the lyrics from Division Bell, so appropriate:

“Beyond the horizon of the place we lived when we were young
In a world of magnets and miracles
Our thoughts strayed constantly and without boundary
The ringing of the division bell had begun…

Looking beyond the embers of bridges glowing behind us
To a glimpse of how green it was on the other side
Steps taken forwards but sleepwalking back again
Dragged by the force of some sleeping tide
At a higher altitude with flag unfurled
We reached the dizzy heights of that dreamed of world

Encumbered forever by desire and ambition
There's a hunger still unsatisfied
Our weary eyes still stray to the horizon
Though down this road we've been so many times.”

Wednesday, April 28, 2004

CrossRoads

What an incredible journey for the last 6 months. Finally, making it to the list of Class of 2006 in League of MBA Bloggers – strangely I felt the same way as FMG did – as if we are getting separated, going our different paths after having this virtual connection, these virtual friends. Obviously we would like to give each other faces (other than Mark). Probably (as 3app asked) the only way to do it would be to host some sort of get together – I am moving to mid west soon before I move to Ann Arbor and I will have plenty of time to make a trip anywhere. (Most of us probably would as long as we don’t have to fly.) Why not decide on a location and meet? Or probably we will meet in some business case competition or seminar or a conference – who knows?

Laura is the newcomer among the Class of 2006 bloggers, a potential classmate of mine – Laura welcome to the community.

I see a lot of potential Class of 2007 bloggers but mostly Insead applicants – what about that? This year I am suspecting that the list of bloggers will be huge as the fever is really catching on. But it all boils down to one single person – the godfather of all MBA bloggers – Tad Holbie.

Saturday, April 24, 2004

In thiiiss world?

IN THIS WORLD
Country: England (BBC Films)
Director: Michael Winterbottom
Award: Winner, Berlin International Film Festival, Golden Bear – Best Film.
Ecumenical Jury Prize – Peace Film Prize.
Language: Pashtu (with English Subtitles).

Some Facts from the movie:
14.5 million refugees in the world – more than 5 million refugees in Asia – 1 million refugees in Pakistan’s northwestern frontier Peshawar, mostly Afghani who fled the Russian invasion of 1979 and US led bombing campaign of Afghanistan.
7.9 billion dollars – US spent on the bombing campaign in Afghanistan.
Daily ration for an Afghani refugee – 480 grams of wheat flour and 25 grams of vegetable oil.
Each family is provided a tent, a plastic sheet, a blanket and a stove.
Annually 1 million people give their lives at the hand of people smugglers – most of them die on the way, some get caught by authorities and some survives.

It is a horrific and dramatic story of two Afghan refugees’ journey to freedom from the northwestern frontiers of Pakistan to London, England through the countries: Iran, Turkey, Italy and France. The movie depicts the desperation these people will take to escape persecution and the life threatening conditions they face along the way. The main character of the movie is a young Afghan boy called Jamal, a refugee orphan who worked in a brick factory and got paid less than $1 a day.

I have never seen such vivid emotions revealed in a piece of art with such grace. Especially you get entangled with the characters as if you have embarked on a journey with them. And imagine traveling from Pakistan to England by land and particularly avoiding getting caught – spending an evening surrounded by vegetable crates in a truck, crossing an entire mountain by foot on a chilly night, surviving in a 10 ft by 10 ft closed box with 6 other people for 40 hours without food and water, using wooden planks to lie under the belly of a truck for an entire day. And all this for what? Freedom…
More about People Smuggling

Somehow the movie reminded me of David Carter’s Pulitzer Prize winning photograph – a starving Sudanese girl dragging herself towards the United Nations Camp and a vulture in the background waiting for her to die. The civil war at Sudan in the 1990s cutoff a majority of the Sudanese population from the UN relief supplies leading to millions of people dying out of starvation.
More about Carter and his photograph

Civil war still goes on in Africa; Middle East is in a cyclical turmoil of violence for decades; Violence is still the most potent form of negotiation for many countries – and all this for what? - A piece of land, or oil, or a political agenda.
Statistics of War Casualties of the 20th Century

A must-see movie; 4 and a half stars, and not for the weaker hearts.

Monday, April 19, 2004

MBA Advice - How to keep it alive?

The only way to rekindle our mbaadvice site is to request all incoming MBA Class of 2006 to send us articles with their names and the schools they are headed to. We will post the articles with a nametag and “School X Class of 2006” – thus we will involve the entire incoming class in contributing articles for the site. OR else it is impossible for us to keep posting a new article everyday and keep the blog alive. So any MBA Class of 2006 reading this blog – we request you to email us articles with your name and the name of the school you plan to attend (the article can be about anything as long as it is helpful for prospective MBA students).

And Trip – is it possible for you to update the introduction blog with the latest information? I presume we cannot edit each other’s post. The best way to do it will be to post in the format of:

Techiedude – MBS Class of 2006.
FMG – Wharton Class of 2006.

Etc. etc. Sorry to bother you man but I can’t edit your post :) And after all you are the godfather of the mbaadvice blog. I will be starting a thread in business week requesting for articles but will need help from all of you to keep the thread alive. If you guys/gals have any further ideas feel free to share it in the “Comments” Section or we can schedule a chat in jeamish’s blog.

Sunday, April 18, 2004

Just a Show

The mere obsession with a reality TV Show, “Apprentice”, among the business world is driving me nuts – come on people, it is just a reality show with pure entertainment values – considering it as a form of a business course in a business school is purely outlandish. I don’t agree that it provides lessons regarding real-life business situations – to me it is just the editorial cut of a drama in a reality show. And by the way, if Mr. Trump was seriously searching for that ultimate guy or gal to be his apprentice, will he provide a candidate like Omarosa a second chance? The show is nothing but a process of minting money for NBC and an advertisement for the “Trump” brand name.

But I would say that Trump is a genius, just at the time when his Taj Mahal is almost bankrupt (though 2% of his portfolio), he comes up with this brilliant idea of a reality show which not only un-tarnishes his image but also makes “Trump” a house-hold name – needless to say this will help him a lot not only in his businesses but also in opening doors for future opportunities. If you guys noticed, Taj Mahal was there in almost 2 or 3 episodes of the show. And also in one of the show – the competition was to sell “Trump” mineral water. I don’t need to say but it was pretty obvious that Apprentice was an unsolicited advertisement for the “Trump” brand name.

And by the way, did you guys know that Bill also auditioned for the Bachelor? Well, is it pure coincidence or do you start judging the real motives?
Check out it – I was amazed: Bill’s Bachelor Audition.

Tuesday, April 13, 2004

Holier than thou

The recent stance taken by Harvard and Wharton regarding Student and Alumni Surveys has taken the BusinessWeek Forums by storm. Well! I also had the luxury to discuss it in lengths with some of the prospective students for Fall 2005. Everyone agrees that Rankings are a necessary evil. There have been countless debates regarding the authenticity of the rankings and what we achieve in the end. Is it fair to say that School A is better than School B?

But, we are missing the point here. The question is not whether the Rankings are scientific or not? H/W (somehow reminds me of Hardware) have denied the access of students’ and alumni’ contacts to any commercial enterprises. But the question is what the schools are trying to achieve here? Is it respecting student and alumni privacy rights? OR is it denying the customers access to actual insider information? Is it respecting the students’ privacy OR schools’ privacy? Is it actual denial against the Rankings’ hoopla and commercialization OR is it something else?

Personally, to me it is important what the insiders think about their schools. That’s why I considered the Business Week Rankings more while making my decisions rather than US NEWS. To me USNEWS encourages playing the numbers’ game whereas BUSINESSWEEK does not. As a prospective applicant, it helped me a lot to judge about a school based on what the students and alumni think about the school. Keep in mind, when I am talking about this, I am talking about making my decisions among the Top 10 school. And frankly, even before I jumped into the MBA application process, I never ever heard about some schools. Hence, Rankings are a necessary evil and at the same time Student Satisfaction Surveys too – I agree to the point that there is no such reference yardstick, but remember we all have to start from zero. And coming to the argument that a small sample is not a representation of the entire student body – the argument is preposterous, as we all know that random sample taken from a curve is a fair approximation of the entire curve.

Now coming to the point that who is actually losing out in the end if a school doesn’t participate in the surveys – the current students, because the surveys are a way to keep the school on its toes. I know a lot of schools that have actually taken feedback from the student surveys and have implemented solutions based on it. But, I do agree to the fact that publicizing students’ and alumni’ email contacts doesn’t make sense – though encouraging students to participating in the surveys is a fiduciary responsibility of the school – what are they losing out in the end? – This is what I fail to understand.

Either don’t participate in the Rankings at all by not publicizing any statistical data or do it all.

To Summarize:
- Not participating in the student survey doesn’t necessarily denounce Rankings.
- Rankings are a necessary evil and not necessarily scientific.
- In the end, Current Students are the people who would be most affected. Not anyone else.
- Student Surveys are an important yardstick while choosing schools.
It is somewhat important to prospective applicants.
- Participating in Student Satisfaction Surveys is a fiduciary responsibility of the school as long as it wants to constantly innovate.

Thursday, April 08, 2004

WHY MICHIGAN? WHY NOT?

Friday 8:00 AM - 2:00 PM

The drive was a little bit hectic, as we had to reach Michigan by afternoon before the OCD appointment. I needed to pick up a semi-formal pair of shoes, which I thought was appropriate for the event instead of sticking to my good old sneakers, so we headed straight for the mall just on the outskirts of Ann Arbor. [Needless to say, malls are important especially to the significant others.] After shopping we headed straight towards Assembly Hall where I was supposed to meet Al Catrone for my pre-career counseling. While I was waiting in the OCD office, one of the office staff accosted me and asked me who was my counselor; I said, “Mr. Catrone.”; there was a student sitting in the lounge and he told me, “Make sure you call him, Mr. Catrone.” [Everyone calls him Al.]

Friday 2:00 PM - 4:00 PM

The session was very insightful as I learned the intricacies of the recruiting process, where I currently stand and how I can reach my final goals. It appeared that the OCD office would willingly help any current student or alum with the job search process even if it were self-directed. [After I returned I had some questions, which I directed to Al through an email and got a prompt reply.] To summarize, it was a positive experience.

As I came out of Al’s office, there - there was Kris Nebel, who quickly congratulated me on my admission. In all, the staff was very friendly always with a smile. I was quickly contemplating that here was the place where my file was lying – getting mutilated by the admissions staff. And here I am now attending GBR…

Friday 5:30 PM

I was quickly able to locate my student host, an MBA1. I think the school fixed the couples with the couples, which made sense, as the SOS is such a big part of the Michigan community. The students were unbelievably friendly and hospitable, never a frown in their face – needless to say a happy bunch of MBAs. He quickly handed us the meeting place for the dinner before we headed for Dean’s Welcome.

Friday 6:00 PM - 7:00 PM

Location: Hale Auditorium
Attendees: 280 admits, 100 significant others.
“Welcome to Michigan, Congratulations on getting admitted and we welcome you to Ann Arbor.” “We never made a mistake before with the admitted class since I became the Admissions Director and it is so good to see you all finally in person. We all are proud of you.” Dean shared some stories with us – what is Michigan doing to be more responsive to student demands, how C.K. Prahalad showed up in his office after he gave a pep-talk to the Faculty about doing something different, how he cringed as Prof. Prahalad came up with the list of financially deficient companies in the developing countries for the XMAP Project, the new Kellogg Star Professor who would be teaching the marketing core, the revised core curriculum ( the initiatives he took and the resistance he faced) and how Michigan has been consistently doing good as a General Management Program. His sense of humor was impervious. One thing was clear by now, Michigan will provide a lot of opportunities and the onus is on us to utilize it appropriately – hence the term, “Co-Creation”. Before the welcome I already accosted a bunch of attendees and had pretty decent conversations with them – everyone was eager to talk to one another.

Friday 7:15 PM - 9:30 PM

We reached the restaurant by 7-15 PM. There were 2 admits with their SOS and us along with 3 current students with their SOS. First of all let me tell you that the food was awesome – it seemed like Ann Arbor has 423 restaurants. Food is important to me and pointless to say, I was very happy to learn that fact. The students were very eager to answer any questions we had, we all felt like a big huge family – the sense of camaraderie and fellowship was intoxicating. Oh!! We were getting late for the “Welcome Michigan” Party.

Friday 10:00 PM - Saturday 2:00 AM

When we reached Crowne Plaza it was well beyond 10-00 PM. As we dropped our coats, we could hear the buzz all around – the banquet hall was filled with MBAs and staff and faculty. “Smoke on the Water” by a Jazz Band was new to me. There were various games available with pool tables and basketball hoops et al. It was a little bit overwhelming with so many people under a single roof but as I started walking around and talking to people, I slowly got settled. The mix of people was amazing with different cultural and professional backgrounds, different interests. Even the Indians had such diversity that I was amazed. [The school did a good job of admitting a mix of quality applicants.] All the students and faculty I talked to were all gaga about the school. I had tremendous fun that night though I missed Dean Dolan’s dance at the after-party, which was about at 3-00 am Saturday night whereas I left around 2-00 am.

Ria was already sold by then – she constantly restated that I have made the right decision. [Hell Yeah!!] Ria never felt like a significant other – some of the people talked to her more than me.

Saturday 8:30 AM - 12:30 PM

Oops!! Saturday Morning – 8:00 AM, quick breakfast and then Transformation Simulation Kickoff at 8:30 AM. We were randomly grouped and I landed the role of a Director of Finance – this was my first real-life experience of working with a group of strangers on an ambiguous problem. The bonding was imminent and the diversity was exciting. Though we sucked in the 30 seconds commercial bit – the experience was undoubtedly enlightening.

Saturday 12:30 PM - 2:00 PM

We met again in Hale Auditorium where we exchanged our opinions about the experience with our lunch boxes. A Special Programs Panel - Zell Laurie Entrepreneurial Center, Public and Policy Management, Tauber Manufacturing Institute Program, Wolverine Venture Fund, Tozzi Center etc, followed this. It was good to learn that UMICH provides such astounding opportunities that can be easily leveraged to our gain.

Saturday 2:30 PM - 4:00 PM

By this time I have totally fizzled out – I was dog-tired. I badly needed some rest. So I headed straight to the hotel for an afternoon siesta.

Saturday 4:30 PM - 5:30 PM

When I returned the Alumni Panel had just started. There were folks from American Express, Union Pacific, Apple, a start-up, Bain Consulting Company and Goldman Sachs. The Apple alumni said that they only recruit from 4 schools because the culture of the school is very important to them. [He mentioned Kellogg and Michigan.] The entrepreneur alumni talked about how Michigan opened the doors for her, how the school has helped her with starting the company? [How he called up the professors for their opinions?] The Bain guy told about how he is fighting to make Michigan on top of the list of Bain recruiting. The Goldman Sachs alumni talked about the predominant presence of Michigan MBA in Wall Street and in Manhattan. [He said he took 16 credits in the last quarter – how can one do that?] Weather is a factor in Michigan but compared to the opportunities – it is miniscule. The alumni seemed very passionate about the school and they eagerly answered any questions we raised.

Saturday 6:00 PM - 7:00 PM

Before the dinner, we stepped into a roadside café in the Central Campus. As the rain down poured, we munched on a hot croissant and sipped on caffe latte, enjoying the evening in a quintessential college town.

Saturday 7:00 PM - 9:00 PM

The dinner was hosted at a current student’s apartment - Barbeque Grill. The Final Four game was on the TV and most of the conversation surrounded Football and Basketball. Football is a big part of the Michigan’s culture and “Maize and Blue” has become synonymous with “Go Blue”. One of the current students went for IMAP to Ireland and as he was walking across the terminal one stranger (Michigan alum) shouted “Go Blue”, probably recognizing the M emblem on the T-shirt. It seems like one Michigan MBA1’s 2-yr old kid mumbles “Go Blue” whenever he sees the M emblem.
As we enjoyed the dinner and the cordiality, we also learned a lot about the school. Brand Management is very strong in Michigan and most of the grads wishes to pursue a career in Brand Management. [Most of the people I talked to.] I got my legged pulled a little bit for a crime that I didn’t commit. [Similar to the cell phone incident during Dean Dolan’s speech.] Ria was having a blast with the significant others – I was a little bit surprised to see her enjoy it so much.

Saturday 9:30 PM - 11:00 PM

Studio-4 and Irish Pub
Nightlife at Ann Arbor
Some of the Michigan Clubs hosted a get-together in various bars across town. The loud music in Studio-4 with free drinks is too enticing an environment to pass up getting inebriated. As I gulped down a couple of beers I made some incredible friends – by this time I was completely blown away by Michigan’s culture of “Play Hard, Work Harder.” Some of the admits started dancing in the dance floor with all the disco lights and techno-music.

Saturday 11:30 PM - Sunday 1:00 AM

Hill House Party.
I was already half-stoned when I reached Hill House. I could see the bar fountain under the tent. As soon as I entered, I was immediately pulled aside with a current student to try something, “You guys have to try this.” There was this huge ice slab kept in a slanting position with two grooves zigzagging across the surface. As they poured a mixture of Vodka and Whiskey from the top we were asked to sip it from the bottom. Man, it hit me harder than regular tequila shots at the bar – everything seemed so hazy. When I went inside I learned that some of the current students were giving Salsa dance lessons – I was too stoned to try that though Ria was much more enthusiastic than I was. Saturday night ended with me slumping on the bed at 1-00 AM.

Sunday 9:30 PM - 10:30 PM

OCD Panel
Al started the session with a joke that he is always assigned the Sunday morning slot when very few people turn up. [Especially after getting stoned on Saturday nights at Hill House.] Anyway, we got the numbers. With 4 weeks to graduations, and 83% of the Class of 2004 reporting, 75% have received offers and 67% have accepted the offers – much higher than last year. He touched base on the high rank of the career office and Michigan grads among recruiters. He also gave us some tips about preparatory work in the summer to enhance our candidacy. And yes, the recruiters starts coming the very next week the class starts.

Sunday 10:30 PM - 12:30 PM

Then I attended one of the Classes by a Michigan Strategy Professor – got a very good feel about the classroom and the quality of education. Not to mention the diversity of my classmates and their startling experiences. Till now we didn’t get any time to check out the business school or the campus – so we decided that we would take a walk along the campus. I liked the campus – some of the buildings were very archaic (1800s architecture).

Sunday 12:30 PM - 2:00 PM

We were just in time for the GBR closing ceremonies. The Hale Auditorium was again buzzing with people. It started off with a presentation by Linda Lim, the Strategy Professor – the entire Hale Auditorium was rolling in laughter throughout her session. [Do all professors have such good sense of humor?] Some Trivia Quiz and a lecture by the current UMBSA president followed it. Then a group of Michigan students sang a few numbers starting off with Madonna’s “Like a Prayer.” It ended with “Hail Michigan” – we noticed that all the current students, staff and alumni stood up during the song with their fists held high in the air chanting “Hail!!”
After this there was a slide show, which almost captured all the sentiments of GBR.
Finally in the end, we were asked to sing the “Hail Michigan” song together – think about it, almost 200 people in the Hale Auditorium singing together:

“Hail! to the victors valiant
Hail! to the conqu'ring heroes
Hail! Hail! to Michigan
the leaders and best
Hail! to the victors valiant
Hail! to the conqu'ring heroes
Hail! Hail! to Michigan,
the champions of the West!”

It was difficult to part in the end. After such an amazing weekend, how can someone work? How one will get the motivation to stick here for the next few months?

20 weeks and counting…

SOS Perspective:
  • Ria's Post
  • Tuesday, April 06, 2004

    GBR was a blast

    GBR was such a blast, probably one of the most memorable weekends of my life. I have never met such an awesome group of people- ever. Ria was totally blown away by the school's culture. I will always reminisce Dean Dolan dancing at the after-party on Saturday morning (3-00 am); Transformation Simulation; bar-hopping on Saturday evening; party at Hill House ; getting stoned while sipping vodka and whiskey from an ice slab; the career counseling session with Al Catrone; dinner at a student house; alumni panel; the classroom experience and then ending GBR with the entire Hale Auditorium singing "Hail Michigan - the champions of the West."

    What an experience!! Details will follow...